Anyone who has ever had an MRI knows that being moved into a small tunnel for long periods of time is not the most pleasant experience. So when Open MRI's became available, many patients began requesting the new machines. Imaging centers even started advertising the fact that they had Open machines.
For the large and very claustrophobic patient, the Open machine filled a valuable place. Without it, these patients could not be scanned and were often subjected to more invasive diagnostic procedures.
However, there was a price for the openness of the machine. Though not widely publicized, quality differences were significant. First, Open MRI's take about twice as long as traditional units to complete the same scans. In fact, acquisition times are so slow certain procedures are not even possible.
Second, there has always been a significant clarity difference between images acquired in traditional MR scanners and those of open machines. The magnet used in open machines has a very low field strength compared to that of tunnel scanners. The open produces a fuzzier or less clear image. The medical community accepted these short comings because the Open Scanner filled an important gap for the large and claustrophobic patient. |